tv The Stream 2019 Ep 190 Al Jazeera November 28, 2019 5:32pm-6:01pm +03
deemed responsible for human rights abuses. hundreds of people are showing their gratitude with a pro us rally in central hong kong. thanksgiving present. the french president has rejected a more terror moratorium offered by russia on short term and medium range missiles he made the comment during a meeting with nato. paris russia proposed the suspension after a ban on the move was lifted in august rescue workers in albania are running out of time to find survivors from tuesday's earthquake $41.00 people are now confirmed several countries have also sent teams to help. those are the headlines on al-jazeera more news coming up after the stream thanks for watching. kind of. pick up the car. we bring you the stories and developments that are rapidly
changing the world. so is it possible for trump to actually. come to the coast. and you're in the stream today protests in a wrong what happened was the country's internet was shot all people inside iran for an update and since several of our community members for quested today's topic we want to hear from you what questions you have for our guests send us a tweet or join the live chat streaming right now on youtube. this is just the ramsi and the communications director of human rights in iran and here in the green. a sharp increase in the price of petrol saying to run the ends to the streets this month in anti-government demonstrations that turned deadly
and destructive protesters burned banks government buildings and clashed with police following in november the 15th fuel hike according to amnesty international more than 140 people were killed in various protests across the country that death toll has been disputed by the iranian government part of terrans response will stay shut down the internet for several days creating even more challenges in verifying the extent of the rest on wednesday iran's supreme leader said the protests have been contained he also blamed demonstrations on a conspiracy involving the united states so with us to discuss iran's fuel price protests and the fallout there are more deserving journalist and diplomatic correspondent with the independent into her say and most of them political analyst and professor of media studies also into her on al-jazeera correspondent bari and there what is really good to have you i actually want to start with
a comment from november 27th from iran's supreme leader and the reason he felt the protests got under way and who was behind the protests have a miss. chad i just go there with it and i say that you see it was a deep extensive and very dangerous conspiracy that cost them the us so much money and effort so they wanted to use an opportunity to carry out this move which was an act of destruction arson murder and vandalism under the pretext of a gasoline price increase they thought that they had found the opportunity and brought their troops to the field this move was destroyed by the people that pay those are the most of all that is want. some volved it's a plot if you will looking at what happened over the last couple of days how much a kite to rise what happened what took people out on the streets. well thanks for
having me well let me explain it this way that protests are different from briards you know all throughout the world when the plans come into effect and people take out to the streets to express their fuel in anger and their concerns it will witness the sense of throughout europe and in the west following that through 1008 economic meltdown we are still witnessing the yellowest are alt for economic reasons in paris out the 4555 weeks and the same happened in a lot of prison will honey rot. gas rationing and gas hide the gas price. plan into effect in a wrong way as a matter of fact i don't i don't think that you would find any kind of economist throughout the world that would support payment of a nationwide subsidy is special leave for petrol to the whole nation but what
matters here is that there is no honea it is the wrong time in the wrong way actually for exercising a state solve this issue and you need to go through stages 1st is expert studies in this case it's been done and then the legitimacy of the executor of the plan the one that implements it was ok but the problem here is a look at their set that is the relevant public support it took people off guard people were surprised everyone was surprised and then people took out to the streets to their legitimate grievances against this economic policy approaches the a hottie that came by surprise but from a certain point and as usual you're not in the states and the number of other you know opposition forces that it meant that actually their involvement through the opposition media and you know abroad. in england at least in london there have been
2 t.v. channels that opposition members who believe in the regime change even some of them through war and force and the absence of a graduate can i just get you close for a moment because you pull up so many different issues and i feel that we can. contribute to some of those issues let me just go this is just let me just let me say that they they try as usual the united states and a number of these regime change guys that are playing into the end of the u.s. like the any right it is a sign of the form xabi trying to hijack the protests and as a matter of. those the best route riots and those who help all be legitimate grievances against this economic plan when they saw their security was at the stake they got back home and if you're in pro stop living but i suggest that i pause for a moment because i have several issues that you're all talking about at the same time i want other people to to weigh in here dosa so when most of us started was
that the legitimate grievances and perhaps this was not the best economic move at the time money could have been done better you were reporting on these pilot tests how did you count to rise them for us as an audience at al-jazeera for instance. well i think most that i was right initially everybody was shocked imagine waking up one morning on a weekend on friday morning november 15th and finding out the price of gasoline had tripled overnight without any reason given by the government i think people initially thought that by taking their grievances out on the streets it would help to put pressure on the government to reverse this decision but once we heard from the supreme leader on that following sunday we knew that this decision was final he expressed his support for the government's decision and he said that anybody who
protests and this tries to destroy government buildings he described these people as thugs and hoodlums and then we heard within a few hours from the intelligence ministry who said that the words of the supreme leader are final and that they will do everything they can to bring security and stability back to their country and then the monday of that week we heard from the revolutionary guards they also issued a similar statement saying that they are now going to go out in full force and restore order in the country i think it's worth noting also that. this protest actually didn't start in the capital it started in it which is one of the largest cities in the country and that was the starting point and then it spread to other cities in the country but we never really saw that kind of mobilization of that kind of violence at all in the capital during the entire time and i would say within the 1st $3.00 to $4.00 days once the revolutionary guard in the in terrell intelligence ministry came into the scene and decided to prevent this from
spreading it actually went away quite quickly and also the most important thing i think was the internet shutting off within 24 hours that these riots broke out by saturday evening we started noticing that our mobile phones no longer had internet and then everything slowed down and by the evening it was. an all out blackout in the country and that is something that's very rare it hasn't happened here before and it was a very very specific decision that was made it wasn't just made by the information minister or the interior ministry it was made by a specific organization that is called the supreme national security committee and they are tasked with serious issues making very important decisions it's headed by the president hassan rouhani as well as the head of the judiciary and the speaker of parliament and their decisions are actually. the final say after they make decisions is approved by the supreme leader so this group
has a tremendous amount of power and decides of what direction the country goes in domestically as well as with it when it comes to iran's foreign policy and also its nuclear program so ok there are a lot of different elements at play but i think the most surprising decision was the internet blackout and to that point because of the internet blackout it was so difficult and still is really to figure out what is happening on the ground and what the realities are so i want to bring up this we. actually know our base and what your service saying i mean here on twitter says watch the videos which have been shared by hash tag iranian protesters you can not find someone saying please make the gasoline cheaper they all say they don't want this regime anymore so talk to us about what you're seeing or what you were hearing and why people are out in the streets was it really the fuel increase the fuel price increase or was that just the spark to underlying discontent just so to adore so saying
this decision wasn't just made by the administration it was made by all different factions the highest echelons of power in the entire state so it's not just one side of the political system and it was definitely ignited by the hike in fuel prices like dorsal and we can you wake up and it's tripled. but then it quickly turned political the slogans become political whereas the economy is essentially political because if you see the mismanagement of the government if you see high corruption within different factions all the way to the top of this state it just adds to that people feel like the economic misery the crisis that they're in is actually part of the way the country is being ruled which is very political and that's why we hear very radical slogans on the street it's actually not the 1st time we're hearing this has been a continuation of the end of 201-7800 that were series
a series of protests in multiple cities across iran but what's new is that. there had been intermittent shutdown of internet in areas where there are protests on mobile phones or things like that but this complete blackout of the entire country home and phone is just a very terrible. basically no one thing they knew this to get out and it was semi-successful let me show you and you can listen to iran's communication minister he makes an apology and explains why the internet was shut off in iran have a look have a listen. to the heavy responsibility of maintaining peace and security of the country is on the shoulders of top security bodies at the beginning of the unrest the decision to limit the internet was taken to ensure peace for the society and the people and then it was the liberty internet offering. i should apologize on my behalf for all the problems you have been through during this period on my behalf and as a member of the government and the room. was about how do you name it how does that
happen. well let me add up couric the number of mistakes in here offers about the internet the media personnel of news agencies they were as well as some media outlets they were not disconnect that they had the them that 1st of all and the very fast the iranian ministration is the army tried hard to bring back a number of centers online like a number of academic centers in each cities as well as saw some of the i mean some sectors that vitally needed that matz like funnel for follow up. to so forth but only a minor 2nd point is. some some people are trying hard in order to exonerate president rouhani that ministration can be projecting the blame on everyone and this stop placement that's not the case since i have lots of
documents and information about this as a journalist and i know the president rouhani as i said before everyone is supporting that we thought sion or reduction of stocks of these or pockets ups of these so much i listed i just didn't think i going to usually buy back on the topic because it was something i was really curious about and use a journalist would be at appreciate as you know that how do you just how do you mean to say listen to mine about this yet then you keep saying let me just do this and i'm really curious and you have a 2nd show i'm outa the op how do you limit the internet in iran how to how do you deal yet. 1st of all every one was brought back i mean then that more by as well as the ok i don't want to answer it but i just would like to get a nazi if possible i how do you know the internet in iran why not well this is something that you need to ask the officials not me they have if you already complicated. this are right because i'm not an artsy guy 1st of all
let me explain a little about that was part of the old harney actually who chose the timing who chose actually the manner of its implementation he had a number of other options to earn the same amount of money that he plans to earn through rationing petrol we could have done you know a lot of other things including for example according to data and claims that been presented to him on making petrol engine what can he see me because we believe going to the internet and the internet imitation has happened over the last couple of days and and now it's beginning to come back again because there are a lot of people that are trying to i'm sorry about that but there are many people who are trying to clean the audio up this wrong move and i don't know why because there are facts on the ground provide us with this very simple for our.
prism ok so i'm going to just put on pause for a moment. can you move us on a course because we are an internet savvy show and we rely on the internet to power us this was the number one thing that people wanted us to know about iran so just want to share a few tweets from people to cover this as one of them who said at the time this is november 20th the internet blackout in iran has been going on for almost 100 hours coverage would put pressure on the government to turn it back on maxima says the of the shutdown has created an echo chamber inside iran nor to prevent the news of a by. and crackdown on protesters from getting out but i want to share with our audience this graphic because this will share this will show you exactly what it looked like so this from that block or an update 65 hours after iran implemented a near total internet shutdown some of the last remaining networks are now being cut and connectivity to the outside world has fallen further to 4 percent you can
see this here this is november 19th now we got a comment from someone who works at this organization on what it's like now he's actually the actually the executive director at that blocks here's what he told the stream. it's been almost 2 weeks. so. you know you. can actually be very serious incident take. your seat. that. you see filtering through to shut down. some state. country which seems to come to mind but. if you don't really understand it. even if you may she. reaches the outside world you're going to see how you defend. against. it there is pressure. against you for its needs 1st.
cinnabar i know that you had some connectivity you were able to connect to some of your family and friends back in iran but what does this mean on a wider scale what did the shutdown mean for people in the 1st place well we heard from people who feel like they're suffocating it feels like their prison feels like their screen when nobody can hear them. it went on for quite a long time i mean we can talk about economics behind the fuel price for it but that's not what the story is anymore it moved way beyond everyone within the administration is an agreement that was the wrong will get there on time but then what happened during the these protests and some comparisons were made with austerity measures in other countries and protests but you have over 140 people. international house put. right now probably. very violent thousands of people have been arrested 7000 people one member of parliament has said that have been arrested and just from the very. small number of images videos and photos that come out we
see a very brutal crackdown in some instances security forces directly shooting up protestors or just violence happening in addition to all the valid bills and that went on in the anger that was on the street but this number of deaths in this much crackdown in just one week is very good on president. to sign just looking at some of the reporting that you did for us on al-jazeera and it's quite difficult that that blackout time when we couldn't see the video all the videos and now popping up and then we have to work out which ones we can verify which ones we caught but in time what can you tell us happened in that time when we had limited access to what was happening in iraq. well it was very difficult for us to even do our jobs in those circumstances not only did we have limited internet access we were restricted in our movements as well. based
say in those circumstances is for security and we really choose not to venture too far away from the office because we don't know what the restrictions are of any given moment so we smilies stay within our offices and rely on state television and other official news channels to do their reporting and since we can't really verify any of the events the protests or the riots we try to find a balance in between what we hear from the official channels here and what we hear from those unofficial channels outside of are on the move people send their alleged firsthand accounts of what happens at these protests and riots so we try to present both sides and figure out sort of a happy medium if you will in the middle somewhere but really it's very very difficult. it's hard to for anybody to verify these videos at any given moment
anywhere in the world i think that's just that given the nature of social media there were images that were allegedly from you know 5 years ago from 10 years ago writing that took place in the house there were allegations that some of the social media footage was coming from iraq that protests there again it's very difficult for us to verify that kind of information all we can do is really try and present a picture of what is happening where we are and that is the capital we spoke to people in the streets on a few occasions in during that 1st week just to get their opinion about what they thought how this price hike would affect their daily life and i think it was interesting that we heard from the president hassan rouhani on that sunday about the reason he gave for doing. this and he even acknowledged that it was a very difficult decision for his government but given the sanctions that this country finds itself on here they didn't have
a choice they had to do something because they were going to run out of money they had to find a way to increase the budgets the income for the government and to try to help nearly 60000000 iranians that are living below the poverty line i was they and their notion of and by them is going to jump them must have a go ahead may jump in although that's that's a wrong bet bets are on the understanding of what prism how that is so on is that rouhani has been claiming that they are not going to make any kind of revenue through this new scheme he has just that somewhere around 31. $1010.00 mins would be the earning the estimates show actually every bit of the average ryall of it would be given to the lower classes of the society so this plan is basically not related to the sanctions directly but of course as sanctions make it up our beer make life harder for the lower class society and the president has
to harness come up with this scheme as he says and claims help the poor that's the target of these cash handouts that they say that would be if the probably going to have started giving out to the public. this is not. something that supposed to have been a kind of a rip for president rouhani that's what he claimed and i thank you thank you so late flank you for laying a nasty and i will not live like you're well right at the end of the show most of us i didn't do excuse me i just want to get one more comment from the gulf which is after all of this time the the violence the protest staying on the internet being limited the other end of that what is the fallout of what is happening right now. well it seems like the actual address has been wrapped up was going to be wrapped up with the crackdown now we see but the grievances are not going away this is something that we saw 2 years ago that are probably going to continue if they can
amik situation doesn't change if the political situation the corruption the mismanagement and also the economic sanctions from the outside none of this is changes these grievances are going to go away and people are probably just going to be more angry as you mention the grievances are going to go away we have a question on you tube from elizabeth who says who benefits from gas prices being tripled why won't the government reverse that decision especially since the people are protesting against it do you actually think the government will reverse that decision can they because this is something that other bodies have been asking for recommending that they put this into place. even environmentalist and it's still subsidize the higher hike prices also still subsidize but i don't think it's going to change the governor's promise to take the money that they were going to save from the subsidies and cash part of it to the lower income part of the society has already started to millions of iranian families but i don't think it's
going to translate to the actual number that people are going to lose with the tripling of their prices and then just very briefly you know you have family in a wrong. when you talk to them when you reach out to them how they feeling right now well my friends and family mostly live and. they've been away as dorset from hard of the agressor the violence but it's just the internet shutdown was something that affected everyone and not only us from the outside but even iranians inside iran were not quite aware of what's happening within the country because of the shutdown which is also what now it's like slowly coming out. thank you dorsey thank you must really appreciate you being on the stream today helping us understand the most recent protests as of the time we have thanks for watching.
the brazilian journalist investigating a politically stack's in a land grab all the farmers helped get elected and he's repay them that's empowering everyday people to profit from the destruction of the rain forest people are almost willing to give their life away from daring to see the occupation article and says journalist in the last home in the fight for sleep the amazon the system not only a land conflict but a conflict a narrative brazil the age of boss n r o who's truth is it anyway on al-jazeera. a
$150000000.00 trees disappear every year into the clothing that we all wear from uk cycling to save the forests the famous yellow dress fade from blue jeans. to conserving the world's dwindling wetlands 3 of the aids world's global bird migration watch intersect right where we are the basic discovered a treasure trove it is one of the most special low clouds on the planet at frys ecosystems elaborate on al-jazeera.
al-jazeera. where ever you are. this is al-jazeera. how about and how he'd seen in doha and this is the al-jazeera news are coming out for you in the next 60 minutes welcome back from society prisons dozens of yemenis flown home as part of an exchange deal but well there's been progress in ending the war. last. iraq's army commanders sent to restore order after a violent nice of antigovernment protests on the burning of